He Went Back To His Ex But Still Texts Me

If you hook up with another girl, your chances of getting back together with your ex are greatly diminished. simply find out with either of these posts: Capture His Love And His Full Attention. God wants to open our eyes to "the riches of the glory of his inheritance in the saints" (Ephesians 1:18). You all are fake. He has told me that he would probably start having sex with them again if we don’t work out. I cover a lot of the following: How to get a guy to like you, signs a guy likes you, how to get a guy back, how to get your ex back, how to get him to like you again, how to get a guy to text back. He tried thinking she would let him go. If your ex is still texting you on a pretty regular basis, you can be sure that he's faking that he's moved on. She still has no idea why he went full. Don't keep things from past. I don’t want my ex back I told him this so many times but this only comes out when he drunk. Is My Ex Thinking About Me? Is My Ex Over Me? Does My Ex Miss Me? Do I still matter to my ex? These questions are just going to stop you from getting back together. He fell in love with me and on his own wanted to leave. for helping me get my ex fiance back 2yrs of break up due would go to bed maybe hit the phone for a text. Long story short, I met this awesome guy through my part time job and we clicked immediately. So, of course he won't stop texting her when he. your value to him you may still mainly get texts instead. The Go-to Guide for Making Smarter. I'm at that stage where I don't know if it's a deal-breaker and need to find out if he's going to stand up for himself. Does your crush, friend, ex boyfriend etc ignore you for a reason you don't know ? take this quiz and you will find out :) Why is he ignoring you? Emily. We started dating and he treated me very very well, we went on trips and everything but after few months he told me that he had been talking to his ex for the past week and that they still had an unfinished business and they have decided to give the relationship another try. went unanswered and such. I still love him and I deeply regret what I have done. It’s so frustrating. I am able to pay my bills but all my hard earned money goes to debt he ran up with the promise to pay me back & a home I now own in a state where I know few people. My boyfriend, however, has been with tons of women, and a couple of them were and are his best friends. To tell if your ex still cares about you, watch for friendly and consistent communication, which could be a sign that they want to be a part of your life again. But before you go wild with jealousy, sit down and talk to your guy about how you feel and why he’s still so close to his ex. To anyone dating a married man, thinking he is going to leave his wife, let me say this, if it wasn't for me filing for divorce, he would still be with me with never having intentions on leaving me. It is really not as difficult as nearly all women make it sound. When the paternity test proves he’s the father can he use the threatening text messages I said against me?. It can be hard to tell if your ex wants you back when he keeps texting and disappearing! Most of the time, when your ex texts you out of the blue, it doesn't mean anything big. He seemed to respect his wife but reported that they were living separate lives. Didn’t want me to leave to go home. I’m in love with my Virgo we fall hard for another, But he starting back off. Lets's call him A. The situation got complicated. went unanswered and such. You may give him a chance because you really love him, but that may not be the same reason he gave his ex another chance. Whenever I try to reach out I get messages every 2 or more hours. It so happened that I had heard from her that day before he texted so I was able to let him know that she was okay. I needed to escape his abuse, not prolong things with therapy, I could not get divorced fast enough. He did bring up during that week that we should hang out again soon. Just as you undoubtedly have a past as well. Here are 11 signs he’s using you to get over his ex: He’s still bitter about his ex. His identity has been shaped as a unit with you. Unfortunately, I asked for commitment as he was possessive, he broke up but didn’t let me go. But still, the temptation was there, and I know stronger women than me have fallen prey to the torture of watching your ex move on via Instagram and Facebook. You invite an ex to your wedding, but he doesn’t invite you to his. One of the signs that your ex wants you back is if he volunteers information about himself or things that happened to him lately. Personally, when someone tells me they're still friendly with their ex, I can't help but be a little skeptical. If he is actively involved in his ex's life, he hasn't let her go. I arranged a lovely suite on the beach and we went out for lunch played golf. If you want him back, this is probably the text you've been waiting and hoping for. I got mixed up in the same thing with an ex. And that’s just basic logic, human nature of men being territorial, and exactly how to get your ex boyfriend back. If your ex seems like they want to get back together one day but doesn't want to the next, this article will help you figure out the conflicting messages by your ex to see if they actually want to get back together or if they are just playing games with you. He doesn’t want to break-up, he wants to see his ex as well. With a career spanning four decades, Prince was known for his eclectic work and flamboyant stage appearances. He'll also go over the four deadly mistakes that you could be making right now that are killing your chances of ever getting your ex back. Cristiano Ronaldo names ex-Man Utd team-mate Van Nistelrooy who he ‘fought with’ as one of his inspirations you can still do it at 34-and-a-half years old. What’s good ex-etiquette? A. We have a 1 year old together and I've taken him back. After almost two years of romancing, I finally thought it’s time to settle down. …quickly he text me back saging he is not there anymore but went to a theme park! He hates those places he didn’t last an hour there with me. Will he come back to me? This is the question many women ask themselves after a breakup or a big argument with their boyfriends. But we got back together and went into 7 months a week ago. He probably wants you back if he's always the first one to call. so far, this quiz has been pretty accurate in predicting the correct results. I have chosen my ex a few times, or I wake up before my choice. Here are 14 signs that you should watch for to know if your ex still loves you and wants you back. so you won't see his texts. Second, and more importantly, since he'll probably reply to you via text message, it allows you time to think of a good response. I was starting a graduate program and needed a place near campus. Once he went back to school, he was getting a certificate as an MA. I would always wonder if he was still married, and at one time i had a dream of a ‘feeling that he was divorced, well i was right. As far as you’re concerned, it’s all over and there’s no going back. During the call, he asked me in front of his friend if we can go meet them again. or at least. The contact with his ex increased and I was getting more and more annoyed, and the last morning I saw him (he told me again he loved me), then he went missing for a few days, and I knew where he had gone, back to his ex, text him and told him to get in touch, and he never then got a text a few days later saying he was sorry, had gone back with. A friend of mine told me he saw some testimonies of a spell caster called Dr Kala of ([email protected] My Ex Boyfriend Is Texting Me When your ex boyfriend is texting you it can become very confusing - what does he want? You have to be aware of the possible reasons behind post break up texting to figure out where you stand with him. Oh HELL no. He Shares His Self-Improvement Plans With You. I hurt him too much which is understandable. Sometimes, he calls you for no reason. I thanked him for talking to me and hung up. Here are the 10 useful tips on how to get your ex back after months apart and the things to remember before getting your ex back. And that is definitely not something you should put up with. My ex dumped me just a couple days ago and he said he went back to his ex because the flame came back. We started dating and he treated me very very well, we went on trips and everything but after few months he told me that he had been talking to his ex for the past week and that they still had an unfinished business and they have decided to give the relationship another try. but they still kept in contact. He called me last Thursday night to say he missed me and missed talking to me. HE TALKS ABOUT HER NON-STOP. "If they're texting you that they want to. He Make Excuses To Meet You. He wants to keep these things because it reminds him of his ex. I hope you're paying close attention because I'm about to share with you one of the cornerstones of breakup recovery. My Ex Boyfriend Is Texting Me When your ex boyfriend is texting you it can become very confusing - what does he want? You have to be aware of the possible reasons behind post break up texting to figure out where you stand with him. he had texted me some yesterday and texted me right before he was almost to my house. "Plus, he’ll be more on guard next time you bring it up. This is in Pennsylvania. What can I do to get the romance back?. We had sex for the first time ever. He’s also their scandals won’t go public. It is not easy for women to find a good man, and to be honest it is not easy for a man to find a good woman. Woman's boyfriend uses same ring he proposed to his ex with - and gets utterly roasted. I figure there are at least two different reasons why an ex won't let go. He never explained what had happened, why he chose to go back to her or answered any questions. Its been four days since we broke up and still I can't stop the tears from falling. He has already taken me to court and won a judgment, which I am appealing tomorrow, for $2700 out of the $6000 or so he is trying to get. Not only does he still talk about his ex, but everything he says about her sounds resentful — a huge sign that he’s not over the relationship!. But within weeks that vision died, and he went back to his sinful ways. Looking for romance in all the wrong places? Now, try the right place. You have two options if you want to get them back after being blocked: He blocked me, will he come back? After listing these two options I will go over some strategies to make the following options much more effective. You want to hang out and talk, do fun things together, but not hook up. A girl will appreciate knowing that she is the first person he thinks about in the morning and the last person he thinks about before he goes to sleep at night. Shit though that makes me. He told me that even if I left him, he would never go back to his ex-wife. Whatever the scenario surrounding the breakup between you and your ex, the fact of the matter is that it was probably not something that you were happy about. well, he even tried to break up with me because he wanted to straight things up betweens us and his family. Blessed is the one who reads aloud the words of this prophecy, and blessed are those who hear, and who keep what is written in it, for the time is near. He still bothers me a lot, I am forced to manage his attentions politely. If he brags about his ex constantly or remarks on inside jokes, he's still thinking about her way too much. He went back to his ex-girlfriend. He Make Excuses To Meet You. You're super certain they are stalking you online. "You probably don't get many people who up-date you afterwards (or maybe you do), and I was pretty sure that I had lost all hope after he sent me an email saying he was sticking to his decision to breakup with me. The first is where he comes back and tells me how much he misses me and I end up having to choose between him and my current boyfriend. After the separation, he assured me that we could work things out. Just go thru the motions, you'll come out ok on the other side! She still sends me text. How to Talk to Your Ex Boyfriend; How to Talk to Your Ex Boyfriend. Either way, he is the one who ultimately has control over this. People still accuse me of lying about it. He is still talking to his ex, and it's possible they may get back together. But is the good morning text necessary? Of course not. He's saying, "All the glory I revealed to Moses is embodied in my son. I have told him how special he is to me, and even if I only saw him once a month I would be okay with that. Along With A Husband, Came an Ex Wife - My Husband Talks To His Ex Wife Too Much. Just confront him about this and move out. he also said that he told her she was with me but when i looked at. Simple text messages to get your ex back are the way to go. His Facebook was up and I went to his messages. I am able to pay my bills but all my hard earned money goes to debt he ran up with the promise to pay me back & a home I now own in a state where I know few people. Take a look at your ex’s behavior towards you. This behavior can actually work to the couple’s advantage. Often times, open dialogue can help you to address what is leading them to harass you. To anyone dating a married man, thinking he is going to leave his wife, let me say this, if it wasn't for me filing for divorce, he would still be with me with never having intentions on leaving me. He BEGGED me to take him back and gave up everything to give our marriage a chance, even moving to where I’d moved to out of state. One of them was an ex he’d parted ways with over two decades ago. I also told him dat I hd recd just one sms from him dat he ll call me back later. Give Him An Opening. I have heard many a woman think that their ex may want to get back together because he still takes her calls or answers her texts to him. but he still keeps on coming back. So about an hour later I text hI’m on my way back from the shop close to his moms house saying I’m coming gaan around. If they’re blatantly shoving it in your face or posting all over Facebook about it, such showmanship could be an indicator that it’s just a Band-Aid. He’s been texting his ex My boyfriend and I have been dating for a year and four months, and just a few weeks ago he started hanging out with coworkers from his job. Well, let's dig into your question. Mom's Photo of Blended Family with Fiancé and Ex Goes Viral: 'It Captures All the Love' “We were leaving the hospital after Waylon was born and my son was holding his dad’s hand but he. Why else would he be showing you that he is watching what you are up to? 2. He probably feels like you still like him and want him. I’m really at a loss. But still, the temptation was there, and I know stronger women than me have fallen prey to the torture of watching your ex move on via Instagram and Facebook. he is trying to act like being without me is no big deal, and he told me in the past it drove him crazy when i went 3 days without texting him. Well, look at it this way. If you guys text occasionally, but he is always starting the conversation, he is still into you. He wasn’t over two of his exes. He is still talking with his ex, and there is no possibility that they will rekindle their relationship. If he responds to your texts but rarely starts a conversation, or if his texts seem short and lack emotional investment, it. And he encouraged me to keep up with the nonchalance. She still sees me and we talk very occasionally. He tried thinking she would let him go. After a few days of general chit chat txts he says he still wants to be with me. If your ex boyfriend blocks you from his smartphone but he doesn't block you from Facebook then technically you can still get back in touch with him through Facebook when you want. I was taught that pre-marital sex was wrong. Raj texts back he really likes proms, but when Lucy looks at him funny, he texts that it was auto-correct and that it should be that he likes sports. He called me vacation girl. they all went out the window. It would take hours to get a reply or the conversation would hit a slump. " Then Eli discerned that the LORD was calling the boy. So, if you have ever found yourself in a situation in which you can't read the clues your ex has been sending you and if you have ever asked yourself what are the signs my ex-boyfriend still has feelings for me, this is the text for you. Signs your ex likes you 1. There are common signs he is fighting his feelings for you and it’s possible to confirm your suspicions once and for all. want to go back to the ex. so me and my boyfriend were hanging out yesterday and while were cuddling and stuff and his phone went off and i saw he got a message from his ex. Dear John: He May Not Like His Ex, But His Mom Still Does. But if he says he's still tight with his ex's parents—despite the fact that he "doesn't talk to my ex at all. He "loves" me and wants to be with me forever. I don't think he cares if your on his friends list or anything. I understand that family is important and all, but it feels like he could care less if he sees me or not. Show your ex that attentive girls like being around you. Well, the main reason he’s still doing it is that you keep communicating back with him. Ask LH: How Soon Can I Get Rid Of My Ex-Partner's Stuff? Chris Jager | If s/he is still not responding to texts/emails/calls after all that time, then do with the stuff what you will. Many people also later told me that my ex and the table of women he bought with him and his date where only there to make trouble for me and to make me jealous. We took a break and decided to try again, we were intimate again yesterday and he still hasn't texted me back. Do you think that your ex might want you back? Take up the test and find out what we think of what you should do. How to Attract a Specific Person – Using the Law of Attraction for Love This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I may get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you. She would try to do things to get him back before & during our relationship but he didn’t want her back. Come back to me sweetheart. Find and save ideas about Ex boyfriend quotes on Pinterest. The event went well for me and many people congratulated me. Then, his ex-girlfriend, who he’s always told me was crazy, started texting him and calling him. The Man Vanishes. Long story short, I met this awesome guy through my part time job and we clicked immediately. The more you think about your ex, the less you are thinking about yourself and what is best. for about two years, and more than a year ago he asked me out on a date. Give Him An Opening. I hurt him too much which is understandable. when he does this. The on-again, off-again. He made it known by sending his angel to his servant John, who bore witness to the word of God and to the testimony of Jesus Christ, even to all that he saw. Thanks for the support. Either way, he is the one who ultimately has control over this. Find and save ideas about Ex boyfriend quotes on Pinterest. We went to therapy separately and together, and saw our marriage for what it was: mostly a failure. If you express to him how you feel in a loving manner and he still doesn’t step up then he is likely playing you. Ask the So we talked and he said he wanted to still go out with me, attend events together, have me spend the night but do. But if he says he's still tight with his ex's parents—despite the fact that he "doesn't talk to my ex at all. Just go thru the motions, you'll come out ok on the other side! She still sends me text. But by sending that text, it shows you that he's not willing to shake that from his mind so easily. " Is that really someone you want to hang out with? There's no such thing as "getting" a guy to ask you out again. I waited 20 minutes, I said good, and jokingly said Am I on your mind, and he hasnt texted back. I know he gets texts on his watch so I'm really confused. my fiancé and I been together for four month,we met back in april of 2012,well he at first he use to leave his phone in the car,and we argued cause of it,so I ask him to let me see his phone,and he refused, after awhile I let it go, but it still bothered me! that’s why im trying to find a software or an app that I can have access to his calls and text. And he rarely texts me. He was my everything, and I had expected that we’d end up being together forever. She and I can't stand each other. Despite the former 90 Day Fiance star’s bitter split from Colt, Larissa has said she still loves. ) I also noticed his paranoia. We had taken a break, that I offered, because he is dealing with so many issues financially (lost his job) and with his family. Don’t bring her up. for helping me get my ex fiance back 2yrs of break up due would go to bed maybe hit the phone for a text. Nothing he does or writes appears abusive. It was horrible to realise I had nothing and no one. " Gorka snubbed for Kevin as. He never explained what had happened, why he chose to go back to her or answered any questions. Spencer and Toby then go back downstairs holding hands because Toby has to back to his job. that i am the only person who he felll in love with. Or I want my ex back. I left him last week and am very devastated by it. So I felt I had been on your side, for as long as I had known of what had happened. He couldn’t give the life that i want. in the event that you come back. I haven't had any contact with her for 3 years and out of nowhere today she told me she had a dream about me, and she'd contacted me. Feel your next man before he arrives. But we got back together and went into 7 months a week ago. “He used to sneak me into his Fifth Avenue apartment in a black suitcase. He told me that even if I left him, he would never go back to his ex-wife. Because of this I end up not having energy for my next day’s classes ,my. Find out what's going on in your ex's head, and why he feels this way toward a potential relationship. Why Ex-Pro Bowl Linebacker Doesn’t Fear Patriots’ Offense ‘At All’ as Brady still has Julian Edelman, Josh Gordon and a few versatile running backs at his disposal. And he encouraged me to keep up with the nonchalance. It was just one of those things. Your ex boyfriend won't feel pressure to respond to you right away and it allows him to think of an appropriate response. well, he even tried to break up with me because he wanted to straight things up betweens us and his family. I know you're scared that you may never feel a love that strong again. We went to therapy separately and together, and saw our marriage for what it was: mostly a failure. I live 4 hrs away so he came to see me last weekend. I didn’t talk to him for about 3 weeks and it turns out that he had went back to his ex but couldn’t tell me bc he didn’t want to hurt me. i been dating this guy for six month now, he told me how his ex left him for someone who have more money than him. '" So Samuel went and lay down in his place. If your boyfriend still loves his ex, chances are, he still wants to get back with his ex. The ex wife he said wanted to walk their dog (the dog was only a year old when she left), his last ex as ive said he kept in touch with her because she was threatening , yeah right! , tbh i dont blame the women i blame the man in my situation. 5 movie "Back to the Future," Marty McFly (played by Michael J. You might first point out that he had refused to accept your exposition of faith, which, as you say, all Italy has approved, and that he made no use of your literary cudgel against the dogs you spoke of. went unanswered and such. His wife dislikes you. i looked last night when he was in the shower and he had nothing on there at all. you do all those things and she will be putty in your hands. I don't know the nature of the texts since I haven't snooped - I'm not a BSCB - I've just seen her name pop up on his phone's lock screen. Your girlfriend is scared you'll get bored of her. The on-again, off-again. You had a great date, so why hasn't he called you? 9 Reasons Why He Hasn't Called You Back After Your First Date (From A Guy's Perspective) It's been about two days. If your ex-boyfriend still hasn't changed his Facebook status back to "single" yet, he's in denial that you're broken up. So how can you tell if he still has feelings for you? The biggest way to tell if your ex really still has feelings for you is to determine if he’s acting out of jealousy or envy. The entire time they lived separately, worked out custody arrangements and divided assets. My ex Jeremy keeps texting me and I don't understand why. I've blocked his number but almost have this need to see what he wants? Should I keep it. You had better go to Rome and expostulate with him as to the reproach which he has directed against you when you were both absent and innocent. Is my ex in rebound relationship? Sign 4. If he says yes, but based on the reaction of his sleep points you feel like he’s lying, your best strategy is to drop the subject for now. We had taken a break, that I offered, because he is dealing with so many issues financially (lost his job) and with his family. " He noted that Republicans "are still very much behind Trump" and that some states have already canceled their Republican presidential primaries. and if he doesn't completely block you out then he wont be able to go back to you, if it doesnt work out with a new gf. Why doesn’t he call after sex? If my ex boyfriend doesn’t take my calls, can I still get him back? If he doesn’t answer, should I leave a message? If he doesn’t call back, should I call him again? Why does he text but never calls? He said he’d call but he never did. Your breakup was hard enough, and now your ex won't let it go. and they must get approval to go back and forth. Either you tell him that the communication with his ex is a deal breaker and you leave him, OR you decide that as long as there is no "funny business" going on you're willing to live with it. Have you ever experienced that moment, when you realise that a guy hasn’t responded to your text? You sit looking at your phone, you check to see if your phone is getting a signal, check to make sure that the message was sent and, then, you start to get angry with him. How do I respond to my ex when he texts me saying that even though he is NOT going back with me but he's sorry he Has hurted my feelings by his harsh words. How? Well, for starters they are just going to stop you from concentrating on yourself. When he still didn't get the message, he planted a tracker on her car bombarded her messages and texts pleading with her to take him. It will show if he really does love her, or if he did it to get closure. He talks about the relationship a lot. My husband of two years came home last week after a weekend away “with the guys” and told me he wanted to start dating–specifically his ex. Blessed is the one who reads aloud the words of this prophecy, and blessed are those who hear, and who keep what is written in it, for the time is near. Read on to know more at New Love Times. then another dream right after where I’m still in the same spot but my brother and cousins are playing outside and they are much older than they are now,and my ex is still also there and my ex says that my brother. 9 And Eli said to Samuel, Go lie down, and it shall be if He calls you, that you shall say, `Speak, LORD, for Your servant is listening. still desire your ex lover back or need. It will show if he really does love her, or if he did it to get closure. Its not easy to control your emotions when you're in a emotional tornado. Click here to learn exactly how to make your ex want you back. For some reason, when Rachel turned 30, he suddenly decided it was time to improve his relationship with his daughter, because she was now “old enough to make her own decisions. If I could undo what happened, I would, but since I can’t, I’ll say sorry. As a child, I was brought up very strict. If you're anything like I was and attracted commitment-phobic, toxic men, you may have had the confounding experience of finally getting the strength to stay away from your guy for good, only to have him come back on hands and knees, swearing that he really, really loves you and that he's really changed this time. Hey, that's bad Feng Shui. He couldn’t give the life that i want. but he still keeps on coming back. I feel like a fool. Lets's call him A. Sure it's true that there are exes who become great friends and are actively involved in each other's lives, but you can easily tell the difference between those exes and the exes who are still clinging to the relationship for dear life. A breakup is a tumultuous time for both people involved, where mixed messages can linger past the end of the relationship. Well it simply means that he is in control of the conversation whether he knows it or not. Wish I could tell him that someday. What Does It Mean If He Texts Me Every Day? 1. My Ex Boyfriend Is Texting Me When your ex boyfriend is texting you it can become very confusing - what does he want? You have to be aware of the possible reasons behind post break up texting to figure out where you stand with him. The passing of his grandfather was on his mind most and carried over to basketball. " Gorka snubbed for Kevin as. They exchanged flirtatious banter over text for a week or so before he asked her to go out with him on Monday, September 25. The signs that your ex-boyfriend has moved on from a relationship are often hard to distinguish from signals that he is still longing for you, more broken-hearted and alone than angry and aloof. Love psychic readings can show you if his ex will try again to get him back after they break up again. Be at their side when it’s convenient for you. If he won’t talk about it or seems cagey with his responses, take. He wants to keep these things because it reminds him of his ex. This means that he still has her on his mind even when you are with him. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi originally claimed the. or at least. A few hours ago I had a really weird conversation with an ex. If he is making excuses and concrete plans to meet up, then it’s obvious he is planning to date you again. I'd give anything to have my old ex back and the person he used to be. Remember that you have the power here. He doesn't come home until 4 or 6 a. In fact, my husband has like ZERO contact with his ex. 12 signs you're his "one he made a mistake letting go" 12 signs you're his "one he made a mistake letting go" so they’re hoping you will go back to them. If you try to forbid him from. If he brags about his ex constantly or remarks on inside jokes, he's still thinking about her way too much. I'm trying to make a clean break and he's texting me as if we are still together but our breakup wasn't over anything small. he lets me know what he is doing and that he will call me back. He yelled, broke things, raised his fist and was verbally abusive. And when he is in the middle of something job-related, etc. Signs your ex likes you 1. It so happened that I had heard from her that day before he texted so I was able to let him know that she was okay. I gave him back all his stuff. It has been 4 weeks. The fact-checkers, whose work is more and more important for those who prefer facts over lies, police the line between fact and falsehood on a day-to-day basis, and do a great job. Today, my small contribution is to pass along a very good overview that reflects on one of Trump’s favorite overarching falsehoods. Namely: Trump describes an America in which everything was going down the tubes under  Obama, which is why we needed Trump to make America great again. And he claims that this project has come to fruition, with America setting records for prosperity under his leadership and guidance. “Obama bad; Trump good” is pretty much his analysis in all areas and measurement of U.S. activity, especially economically. Even if this were true, it would reflect poorly on Trump’s character, but it has the added problem of being false, a big lie made up of many small ones. Personally, I don’t assume that all economic measurements directly reflect the leadership of whoever occupies the Oval Office, nor am I smart enough to figure out what causes what in the economy. But the idea that presidents get the credit or the blame for the economy during their tenure is a political fact of life. Trump, in his adorable, immodest mendacity, not only claims credit for everything good that happens in the economy, but tells people, literally and specifically, that they have to vote for him even if they hate him, because without his guidance, their 401(k) accounts “will go down the tubes.” That would be offensive even if it were true, but it is utterly false. The stock market has been on a 10-year run of steady gains that began in 2009, the year Barack Obama was inaugurated. But why would anyone care about that? It’s only an unarguable, stubborn fact. Still, speaking of facts, there are so many measurements and indicators of how the economy is doing, that those not committed to an honest investigation can find evidence for whatever they want to believe. Trump and his most committed followers want to believe that everything was terrible under Barack Obama and great under Trump. That’s baloney. Anyone who believes that believes something false. And a series of charts and graphs published Monday in the Washington Post and explained by Economics Correspondent Heather Long provides the data that tells the tale. The details are complicated. Click through to the link above and you’ll learn much. But the overview is pretty simply this: The U.S. economy had a major meltdown in the last year of the George W. Bush presidency. Again, I’m not smart enough to know how much of this was Bush’s “fault.” But he had been in office for six years when the trouble started. So, if it’s ever reasonable to hold a president accountable for the performance of the economy, the timeline is bad for Bush. GDP growth went negative. Job growth fell sharply and then went negative. Median household income shrank. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped by more than 5,000 points! U.S. manufacturing output plunged, as did average home values, as did average hourly wages, as did measures of consumer confidence and most other indicators of economic health. (Backup for that is contained in the Post piece I linked to above.) Barack Obama inherited that mess of falling numbers, which continued during his first year in office, 2009, as he put in place policies designed to turn it around. By 2010, Obama’s second year, pretty much all of the negative numbers had turned positive. By the time Obama was up for reelection in 2012, all of them were headed in the right direction, which is certainly among the reasons voters gave him a second term by a solid (not landslide) margin. Basically, all of those good numbers continued throughout the second Obama term. The U.S. GDP, probably the single best measure of how the economy is doing, grew by 2.9 percent in 2015, which was Obama’s seventh year in office and was the best GDP growth number since before the crash of the late Bush years. GDP growth slowed to 1.6 percent in 2016, which may have been among the indicators that supported Trump’s campaign-year argument that everything was going to hell and only he could fix it. During the first year of Trump, GDP growth grew to 2.4 percent, which is decent but not great and anyway, a reasonable person would acknowledge that — to the degree that economic performance is to the credit or blame of the president — the performance in the first year of a new president is a mixture of the old and new policies. In Trump’s second year, 2018, the GDP grew 2.9 percent, equaling Obama’s best year, and so far in 2019, the growth rate has fallen to 2.1 percent, a mediocre number and a decline for which Trump presumably accepts no responsibility and blames either Nancy Pelosi, Ilhan Omar or, if he can swing it, Barack Obama. I suppose it’s natural for a president to want to take credit for everything good that happens on his (or someday her) watch, but not the blame for anything bad. Trump is more blatant about this than most. If we judge by his bad but remarkably steady approval ratings (today, according to the average maintained by 538.com, it’s 41.9 approval/ 53.7 disapproval) the pretty-good economy is not winning him new supporters, nor is his constant exaggeration of his accomplishments costing him many old ones). I already offered it above, but the full Washington Post workup of these numbers, and commentary/explanation by economics correspondent Heather Long, are here. On a related matter, if you care about what used to be called fiscal conservatism, which is the belief that federal debt and deficit matter, here’s a New York Times analysis, based on Congressional Budget Office data, suggesting that the annual budget deficit (that’s the amount the government borrows every year reflecting that amount by which federal spending exceeds revenues) which fell steadily during the Obama years, from a peak of $1.4 trillion at the beginning of the Obama administration, to $585 billion in 2016 (Obama’s last year in office), will be back up to $960 billion this fiscal year, and back over $1 trillion in 2020. (Here’s the New York Times piece detailing those numbers.) Trump is currently floating various tax cuts for the rich and the poor that will presumably worsen those projections, if passed. As the Times piece reported: